We decided to keep our black shutters and paint the new door black to match. When the door was first installed, we began the process of staining the fiberglass. It took 4 days for the first coat of stain to dry. Not okay. This prompted us to do a bit more research on after-market staining/poly coating of fiberglass and the good folks of the blogosphere gave a resounding warning of peeling within the first 2 years. Sooooooo, we opted to sand the door, prime it with Kilz to block the stain from bleeding, and paint it black latex semi-gloss. (The interior face of the door was painted white to match the other doors in our home.)
Here's a link to the website, but it looks like they may have discontinued that color. It is slightly darker than the Georgian Gray. The Georgian Gray was almost a perfect match for our light gray siding.)
Two of my favorite details of the project were the Elijay Bronze Lantern by Savoy House and Hawthorne Handleset by Kwikset. Both arrived within 2-3 days of my online order and look fabulous.
We are really looking forward to the temperature rising so that we can fix up the garden beds and bring out some pots for the front porch.